Shop Local My Account Dairy Store / Dairy Milk & Cream Milk & Cream Dairy Alternatives Dairy Alternatives Cheese Cheese Yogurt Yogurt Other Other Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts Featured Products Sort by We recommend Newest arrivals Price: Low to High Price: High to Low Name: A to Z Name: Z to A Whole Milk Yogurt Buy Now Whole Milk Yogurt $5.00 Buy Now Pre-order Whole Milk Yogurt Pre-Order Whole Milk Yogurt $1.50 Pre-Order Fresh Mozzarella Buy Now Fresh Mozzarella $5.00 Buy Now Free-Range Eggs Buy Now Eggs $7.50 Buy Now Gingerbread Cookie Ice Cream Buy Now Gingerbread Cookie Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Nutella Ice Cream Buy Now Nutella Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now S'mores Ice Cream Buy Now S'mores Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Cow Cake Ice Cream Buy Now Cow Cake Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Milk n Cookies Ice Cream Buy Now Milk n Cookies Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Vanilla Hazelnut Swirl Ice Cream Buy Now Vanilla Hazelnut Swirl Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Spiced Chai Ice Cream Buy Now Spiced Chai Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Oreo Cheesecake Ice Cream Buy Now Oreo Cheesecake Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Hermit Cookie Ice Cream Buy Now Hermit Cookie Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Subscribe & Save 6% Butter, Salted Buy Now Butter, Salted $4.50 Buy Now Subscribe & Save 6% Butter, Unsalted Buy Now Butter, Unsalted $4.50 Buy Now Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese) Buy Now Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese) $8.00 Buy Now Atwell's Gold Cheese Buy Now Atwell's Gold Cheese $8.00 Buy Now Ghee Buy Now Ghee $15.00 Buy Now Ghee, Garlic Rosemary Buy Now Ghee, Garlic Rosemary $15.00 Buy Now Ghee, Turmeric-Spiced Buy Now Ghee, Turmeric-Spiced $15.00 Buy Now Sassy Cashews: Cheddah Buy Now Sassy Cashews: Cheddah $8.00 Buy Now Sassy Cashews: Pink Himalayan Sea Salt & Pepper Buy Now Sassy Cashews: Pink Himalayan Sea Salt & Pepper $8.00 Buy Now Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime Buy Now Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime $8.00 Buy Now Bacon Gouda Spread Buy Now Bacon Gouda Spread $8.50 Buy Now Cheese Stick - Chive Cheddar Buy Now Cheese Stick - Chive Cheddar $2.00 Buy Now Cheese Stick - Chili Pepper Cheddar Buy Now Cheese Stick - Chili Pepper Cheddar $2.00 Buy Now Smoked Farmstead Gouda Buy Now Smoked Farmstead Gouda $8.50 Buy Now Garden Vegetable Havarti Buy Now Garden Vegetable Havarti $8.50 Buy Now Sharp Cheddar Buy Now Sharp Cheddar $8.00 Buy Now Extra Sharp Cheddar Buy Now Extra Sharp Cheddar $8.00 Buy Now Pre-order Sun-Dried Tomato & Basil Gouda Spread Pre-Order Sun-Dried Tomato & Basil Gouda Spread $8.50 Pre-Order Garlic Gouda Spread Buy Now Garlic Gouda Spread $8.50 Buy Now Pre-order Horseradish Gouda Spread Pre-Order Horseradish Gouda Spread $8.50 Pre-Order Onion & Chive Gouda Buy Now Onion & Chive Gouda $8.50 Buy Now Aged Gouda Buy Now Aged Gouda $8.50 Buy Now Chipotle Gouda Buy Now Chipotle Gouda $8.50 Buy Now Creamy Havarti Buy Now Creamy Havarti $8.50 Buy Now Dill Havarti Buy Now Dill Havarti $8.50 Buy Now Cheese Stick - Sharp Cheddar Buy Now Cheese Stick - Sharp Cheddar $2.00 Buy Now Crescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese Buy Now Crescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese $6.00 Buy Now Ricotta Cheese Buy Now Ricotta Cheese $6.00 Buy Now Salty Sea Feta Buy Now Salty Sea Feta $5.00 Buy Now Cheddar Cheese Buy Now Cheddar Cheese $7.35 Buy Now Pre-order Cheddar Cheese Curds Pre-Order Cheddar Cheese Curds $7.50 Pre-Order Pirate Spread Buy Now Pirate Spread $7.00 Buy Now Angelito Buy Now Angelito $7.00 Buy Now Vegan Cream Cheeze Buy Now Cream Cheeze $8.00 Buy Now Peppermint Mocha Oreo Ice Cream Buy Now Peppermint Mocha Oreo Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Cold Cocoa & Marshmallows Ice Cream Buy Now Cold Cocoa & Marshmallows Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Banana Peanut Butter Ice Cream Buy Now Banana Peanut Butter Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Brown Butter Pecan Ice Cream Buy Now Brown Butter Pecan Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Chocolate Ice Cream Buy Now Chocolate Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Eggnog Ice Cream Buy Now Eggnog Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Raspberry Sorbet (Ice Cream Alternative) Buy Now Raspberry Sorbet (Ice Cream Alternative) $8.00 Buy Now Tiramisu Ice Cream Buy Now Tiramisu Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Vanilla Ice Cream Buy Now Vanilla Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Sweet Potato with Marshmallow Ice Cream Buy Now Sweet Potato with Marshmallow Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Pumpkin Oreo Ice Cream Buy Now Pumpkin Oreo Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Apple Crisp Ice Cream Buy Now Apple Crisp Ice Cream $8.00 Buy Now Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwich Buy Now Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sandwich $7.00 Buy Now 1 - 60 of 76 items Prev 1 2 1 2 Next
