About Us
Contact Us
Wholesale
Recipes
Shop Local
My Account
Dairy
Store
/
Dairy
Refine by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Offers
Clear
Offers
Clear
On sale
2
Apply
Apply
Category
Clear
Category
Clear
Cheese
25
Milk & Cream
13
Other
9
Yogurt
7
Dairy Alternatives
6
Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts
6
Apply
Apply
Search by phrase
Clear
Search by phrase
Clear
Keyword or phrase
Apply
Apply
Brand
Clear
Brand
Clear
Narragansett Creamery
13
Wright’s Dairy Farm
13
Green Line Apothecary
5
Smith’s Country Cheese
5
Ploughgate Creamery
4
Vermont Creamery
3
Ambrosi
2
Cabot
2
Ocean State Pepper Company
2
Arethusa Farm
1
Azuluna Farms
1
Barrett’s Garden
1
Big Feeling
1
Cabot Creamery
1
Chi Kitchen
1
CocoJune
1
Frontier Co-Op
1
Kite hill
1
Larson Farm
1
Let’s Do Organic
1
Maple Hill Creamery
1
Meyenberg
1
Oak Knoll Dairy
1
Old Chatham Creamery
1
Ronnybrook Dairy (NY)
1
Apply
Apply
Sort by
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Apply
Apply
Show items
Show items
Milk & Cream
Milk & Cream
Dairy Alternatives
Dairy Alternatives
Cheese
Cheese
Yogurt
Yogurt
Other
Other
Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts
Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts
100% Grass-Fed Organic Plain Kefir
Buy Now
100% Grass-Fed Organic Plain Kefir
$8.00
2% Milk
Buy Now
2% Milk
$4.50
A2A2 Whole Creamline Yogurt
Buy Now
A2A2 Whole Creamline Yogurt
100% Grass-Fed, Certified Organic, A2A2
$12.00
Pre-order
Atwell’s Gold Cheese
Pre-Order
Atwell’s Gold Cheese
$8.00
Bacon Gouda Spread
Buy Now
Bacon Gouda Spread
$10.00
Blueberry Lemon Goat Cheese (Chevre)
Buy Now
Blueberry Lemon Goat Cheese (Chevre)
$6.00
Burrata (Fresh Mozzarella)
Buy Now
Burrata (Fresh Mozzarella)
Back in stock 7/3
$8.00
Subscribe & Save
Butter
Buy Now
Butter
$5.00
Buttermilk
Buy Now
Buttermilk
$5.00
Cheddar Cheese
Buy Now
Cheddar Cheese
$7.35
Cheddar Cheese Curds
Buy Now
Cheddar Cheese Curds
$6.00
Subscribe & Save
Chicken Eggs
Buy Now
Chicken Eggs
$8.00
Chipotle Gouda
Buy Now
Chipotle Gouda
$10.00
Cottage Cheese
Buy Now
Cottage Cheese
$5.00
Crescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese
Buy Now
Crescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese
$7.50
Cultured Butter, Espelette (Pepper)
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Espelette (Pepper)
$10.00
Gluten-Free
Cultured Butter, Maple
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Maple
$10.00
Cultured Butter, Salted
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Salted
$10.00
Gluten-Free
Cultured Butter, Unsalted
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Unsalted
$10.00
Sold out
Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese)
Out of stock
Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese)
$8.00
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Buy Now
Extra Sharp Cheddar
$10.00
Fresh Mozzarella (8oz ball)
Buy Now
Fresh Mozzarella (8oz ball)
Back in stock 7/3
$5.00
Goat Cheese (Chevre)
Buy Now
Goat Cheese (Chevre)
$6.00
Non-Local
Goat Milk Butter
Buy Now
Goat Milk Butter
$10.00
Pre-order
Jalapeno Angelito
Pre-Order
Jalapeno Angelito
Goes great on bagels!
$7.00
Light Cream
Buy Now
Light Cream
$3.50
Mascarpone Cheese
Buy Now
Mascarpone Cheese
$7.50
Non-Local
Parmigiano Reggiano (Parmesan)
Buy Now
Parmigiano Reggiano (Parmesan)
Italy
$15.00
Non-Local
Pecorino Romano Wedge
Buy Now
Pecorino Romano Wedge
Italy
$15.00
Pirate Spread
Buy Now
Pirate Spread
$7.00
Plain Angelito
Buy Now
Plain Angelito
Goes great on bagels!
$7.00
Ricotta Cheese
Buy Now
Ricotta Cheese
$6.00
FROZEN
SALE Butter (Unsalted)
Buy Now
SALE Butter (Unsalted)
Frozen on 5/29/25
was
$5.00
Save
$1.00
$4.00
Free or your own price
SALE Goat Milk
Buy Now
SALE Goat Milk
Sell by 6/24
$0.00 or more
Salty Sea Feta
Buy Now
Salty Sea Feta
$5.00
Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime
Buy Now
Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime
$8.00
Sharp Cheddar
Buy Now
Sharp Cheddar
$10.00
New, lower price!
Sheep Yogurt
Buy Now
Sheep Yogurt
$8.00
Smoked Farmstead Gouda
Buy Now
Smoked Farmstead Gouda
$10.00
Sour Cream
Buy Now
Sour Cream
5.0
(1)
$7.50
Whipped Cream
Buy Now
Whipped Cream
$5.00
Whole Milk Yogurt: Plain
Buy Now
Whole Milk Yogurt: Plain
$1.50
Pre-order
Whole Milk Yogurt: Strawberry
Pre-Order
Whole Milk Yogurt: Strawberry
$5.00
Pre-order
Whole Milk Yogurt: Strawberry
Pre-Order
Whole Milk Yogurt: Strawberry
$1.50
Pre-order
Whole Milk Yogurt: Vanilla
Pre-Order
Whole Milk Yogurt: Vanilla
$5.00