About Us
Contact Us
Wholesale
Product Requests
Recipes
Shop Now
My Account
Dairy
Store
/
Dairy
Milk & Cream
Milk & Cream
Dairy Alternatives
Dairy Alternatives
Cheese
Cheese
Yogurt
Yogurt
Other
Other
Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts
Ice Cream & Other Frozen Desserts
Refine by
Â
Sort by
We recommend
Newest arrivals
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A to Z
Name: Z to A
Filters
Clear all
Filters
Clear all
Show items
Show items
Coming Soon: Nov 8th
100% Grass-Fed Organic Plain Kefir
Buy Now
100% Grass-Fed Organic Plain Kefir
$8.00
100% Grass-Fed Organic Strawberry Kefir
Buy Now
100% Grass-Fed Organic Strawberry Kefir
$8.00
2% Milk
Buy Now
2% Milk
$4.00
Pre-order
Aged Gouda
Pre-Order
Aged Gouda
$10.00
Pre-order
Angelito
Pre-Order
Angelito
$7.00
Pre-order
Atwell’s Gold Cheese
Pre-Order
Atwell’s Gold Cheese
$8.00
Bacon Gouda Spread
Buy Now
Bacon Gouda Spread
$8.50
Pre-order
Brown Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Pre-Order
Brown Butter Pecan Ice Cream
$8.00
Subscribe & Save
Butter
Buy Now
Butter
$5.00
Buttermilk
Buy Now
Buttermilk
$5.00
Cheddar Cheese
Buy Now
Cheddar Cheese
$7.35
Pre-order
Cheese Stick – Chili Pepper Cheddar
Pre-Order
Cheese Stick – Chili Pepper Cheddar
$2.00
Pre-order
Cheese Stick – Chive Cheddar
Pre-Order
Cheese Stick – Chive Cheddar
$2.00
Pre-order
Cheese Stick – Sharp Cheddar
Pre-Order
Cheese Stick – Sharp Cheddar
$2.00
Subscribe & Save
Chicken Eggs
Buy Now
Chicken Eggs
$7.50
Chipotle Gouda
Buy Now
Chipotle Gouda
$8.50
Chocolate Ice Cream
Buy Now
Chocolate Ice Cream
$8.00
Pre-order
Coffee Ice Cream Sandwich
Pre-Order
Coffee Ice Cream Sandwich
$7.00
Pre-order
Compost Cream Ice Cream
Pre-Order
Compost Cream Ice Cream
$8.00
Cottage Cheese
Buy Now
Cottage Cheese
$5.00
Creamy Havarti
Buy Now
Creamy Havarti
$8.50
Pre-order
Crescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese
Pre-Order
Crescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese
$6.00
Cultured Butter, Espelette (Pepper)
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Espelette (Pepper)
$10.00
Gluten-Free
Cultured Butter, Maple
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Maple
$10.00
Cultured Butter, Salted
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Salted
$10.00
Pre-order
Cultured Butter, Seaweed
Pre-Order
Cultured Butter, Seaweed
$10.00
Gluten-Free
Cultured Butter, Unsalted
Buy Now
Cultured Butter, Unsalted
$10.00
Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese)
Buy Now
Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese)
$8.00
Eggnog Ice Cream
Buy Now
Eggnog Ice Cream
$8.00
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Buy Now
Extra Sharp Cheddar
$8.00
Fresh Mozzarella
Buy Now
Fresh Mozzarella
$7.50
Garden Vegetable Havarti
Buy Now
Garden Vegetable Havarti
$8.50
Pre-order
Gingerbread Cookie Ice Cream
Pre-Order
Gingerbread Cookie Ice Cream
$8.00
Goat Cheese (Chevre)
Buy Now
Goat Cheese (Chevre)
$6.00
Horseradish Gouda Spread
Buy Now
Horseradish Gouda Spread
$10.00
Light Cream
Buy Now
Light Cream
$3.00
Mascarpone Cheese
Buy Now
Mascarpone Cheese
$7.00
Onion & Chive Gouda
Buy Now
Onion & Chive Gouda
$8.50
Non-Local
Parmigiano Reggiano (Parmesan)
Buy Now
Parmigiano Reggiano (Parmesan)
Italy
$12.00
Pirate Spread
Buy Now
Pirate Spread
$7.00
Pumpkin Oreo Ice Cream
Buy Now
Pumpkin Oreo Ice Cream
$8.00
Ricotta Cheese
Buy Now
Ricotta Cheese
$6.00
Salted Caramel Ice Cream
Buy Now
Salted Caramel Ice Cream
$8.00
Salty Sea Feta
Buy Now
Salty Sea Feta
$5.00
Sassy Cashews: Cheddah
Buy Now
Sassy Cashews: Cheddah
$8.00
Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime
Buy Now
Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime
$8.00
Sharp Cheddar
Buy Now
Sharp Cheddar
$8.00
New, lower price!
Sheep Yogurt
Buy Now
Sheep Yogurt
$8.00
Smoked Farmstead Gouda
Buy Now
Smoked Farmstead Gouda
$8.50
Sour Cream
Buy Now
Sour Cream
$7.50
Pre-order
Strawberry Sorbet (Ice Cream Alternative)
Pre-Order
Strawberry Sorbet (Ice Cream Alternative)
$10.00
Vanilla Ice Cream
Buy Now
Vanilla Ice Cream
$10.00
Pre-order
Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich
Pre-Order
Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich
$7.00
Pre-order
Whole Milk Yogurt
Pre-Order
Whole Milk Yogurt
$1.50
Whole Milk Yogurt
Buy Now
Whole Milk Yogurt
$5.00