Shop Local My Account Dairy Store/DairyMilk & CreamMilk & CreamDairy AlternativesDairy AlternativesCheeseCheeseYogurtYogurtOtherOtherIce Cream & Other Frozen DessertsIce Cream & Other Frozen DessertsRefine by Sort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AFiltersClear allFiltersClear allShow itemsShow itemsPre-orderAged Gouda Pre-OrderAged Gouda$10.00Pre-orderAngelito Pre-OrderAngelito$7.00Pre-orderApple Crisp Ice Cream Pre-OrderApple Crisp Ice Cream$8.00Pre-orderAtwell's Gold Cheese Pre-OrderAtwell's Gold Cheese$8.00Bacon Gouda Spread Buy NowBacon Gouda Spread$8.50Pre-orderBrown Butter Pecan Ice Cream Pre-OrderBrown Butter Pecan Ice Cream$8.00Subscribe & Save 6%Butter, Salted Buy NowButter, Salted$4.50Subscribe & Save 6%Butter, Unsalted Buy NowButter, Unsalted$4.50Buttermilk Buy NowButtermilk$5.00Cheddar Cheese Buy NowCheddar Cheese$7.35Pre-orderCheddar Cheese Curds Pre-OrderCheddar Cheese Curds$7.50Pre-orderCheese Stick - Chili Pepper Cheddar Pre-OrderCheese Stick - Chili Pepper Cheddar$2.00Pre-orderCheese Stick - Chive Cheddar Pre-OrderCheese Stick - Chive Cheddar$2.00Pre-orderCheese Stick - Sharp Cheddar Pre-OrderCheese Stick - Sharp Cheddar$2.00Pasture-raisedChicken Eggs Buy NowChicken Eggs$7.50Chipotle Gouda Buy NowChipotle Gouda$8.50Chocolate Ice Cream Buy NowChocolate Ice Cream$8.00Pre-orderCoffee Ice Cream Sandwich Pre-OrderCoffee Ice Cream Sandwich$7.00Pre-orderCompost Cream Ice Cream Pre-OrderCompost Cream Ice Cream$8.00Cottage Cheese Buy NowCottage Cheese$5.00Creamy Havarti Buy NowCreamy Havarti$8.50Pre-orderCrescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese Pre-OrderCrescendo (Stracchino di Crescenza) Cheese$6.00Cultured Butter, Espelette (Pepper) Buy NowCultured Butter, Espelette (Pepper)$10.00Gluten-FreeCultured Butter, Maple Buy NowCultured Butter, Maple$10.00Cultured Butter, Salted Buy NowCultured Butter, Salted$10.00Pre-orderCultured Butter, Seaweed Pre-OrderCultured Butter, Seaweed$10.00Gluten-FreeCultured Butter, Unsalted Buy NowCultured Butter, Unsalted$10.00Dill Havarti Buy NowDill Havarti$8.50Divine Providence (Gouda Cheese) Buy NowDivine Providence (Gouda Cheese)$8.00Extra Sharp Cheddar Buy NowExtra Sharp Cheddar$8.00Fresh Mozzarella Buy NowFresh Mozzarella$7.50Garden Vegetable Havarti Buy NowGarden Vegetable Havarti$8.50Pre-orderGarlic Gouda Spread Pre-OrderGarlic Gouda Spread$8.50Pre-orderHorseradish Gouda Spread Pre-OrderHorseradish Gouda Spread$8.50Certified OrganicKefir Pre-OrderKefir100% Grass-Fedwas $10.00 Save $2.50$7.50Onion & Chive Gouda Buy NowOnion & Chive Gouda$8.50Pirate Spread Buy NowPirate Spread$7.00Ricotta Cheese Buy NowRicotta Cheese$6.00Pre-orderSalted Caramel Ice Cream Pre-OrderSalted Caramel Ice Cream$8.00Salty Sea Feta Buy NowSalty Sea Feta$5.00Sassy Cashews: Cheddah Buy NowSassy Cashews: Cheddah$8.00Sassy Cashews: Pink Himalayan Sea Salt & Pepper Buy NowSassy Cashews: Pink Himalayan Sea Salt & Pepper$8.00Sassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime Buy NowSassy Cashews: Sriracha Lime$8.00Sharp Cheddar Buy NowSharp Cheddar$8.00Sheep Yogurt Buy NowSheep Yogurt$7.50Smoked Farmstead Gouda Buy NowSmoked Farmstead Gouda$8.50Sour Cream Buy NowSour Cream$7.50Pre-orderStrawberry Sorbet (Ice Cream Alternative) Pre-OrderStrawberry Sorbet (Ice Cream Alternative)$10.00Pre-orderSun-Dried Tomato & Basil Gouda Spread Pre-OrderSun-Dried Tomato & Basil Gouda Spread$8.50Vanilla Ice Cream Buy NowVanilla Ice Cream$8.00Pre-orderVanilla Ice Cream Sandwich Pre-OrderVanilla Ice Cream Sandwich$7.00Pre-orderWhole Milk Yogurt Pre-OrderWhole Milk Yogurt$1.50Whole Milk Yogurt Buy NowWhole Milk Yogurt$5.00
